I like the jersey for the most part and would probably buy it again for $40, but in general it feels like an odd in-between of a race fit jersey and an athletic tee. I'm 6'1" @ 185 lbs and the XL fits snug but not skin-tight around the torso, which is about what I was going for. I don't need to stretch it to zip like I do with their race-fit jerseys. Comfy, soft, no complaints about how it feels really.
I do have two gripes that account for the two-star deduction: (1) while the torso is snug, the sleeves are flappy. You can see this in some of the product pics. It's a bit of a weird look. Either make it all snug (but not race-fit snug) or all flappy, you know? But for $40 I can't complain that much. And (2) considering that the torso is snug, I would have loved some grippier material along the bottom back edge of the jersey. It tends to ride up the back of my bibs, causing bunching and flapping around the shoulders. I keep having to pull it down while I'm riding.