I had one pair of these and one pair of Rapha Cargo Winter Tights starting this season. I just got a second pair of the Black Bib Winter Thermal Tights after evaluating both of the previous for a couple months. For both comfort (pad and bib material), I have zero preference of one over another. I DO prefer the Black Bib's cargo pockets (leg and middle back) over the Rapha (the right leg mesh has mysteriously ripped a hole and the left leg is too small for a phone). Hence when I got tired of doing musical chairs laundry and needed a third pair? Another Black Bibs it is. Just well done Starlight.
I did size up from my regular Black Bibs (Large) to an XL in these per the shop recommendation. Perfect. And for any Rapha wearers wanting a size comparison, I wear a large in both Pro Team/Brevet/Winter Cargo Bibs there. Also a large for any Assos summer/regular bib users.