I am 6' tall & 180 lbs. I own Pearl Izumi ("PI") bibs. I bought the Black Bibs ("BB") size L, same size I bought in PI, & the BB's fit great. (1) The BB pad is fine, at least as good as my PI pads. (2) The outsides of the BB hip pockets are thick mesh; I can see through them. PI's pockets are solid fabric. I don't prefer one pocket style over the other, with one exception: Some PI shorts have a pocket in a pocket. That gives me a double layer of fabric between my skin and my car keys. I like that. (3) The PI shoulder straps are unseamed stretch fabric; the BB shoulder straps have seams. The BB's are easier than the PI's to lay flat, and are wider. I much prefer the BB's. (4) I prefer the BB's for not having an external brand name on them for people to read. (5) The BB's were less-expensive than the PI's. The BB's have become my favorite bibs. I since bought the BB shorts (not bibs) style, but I prefer the BB bibs to the shorts. Personal preference; I also prefer PI bibs to PI shorts. I'm likely to buy the BB tights for this winter. I already bought the BB gloves, & summer & winter jerseys, & I plan to leave 5-star reviews on them soon.